MackerelSalad's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[Tome89 - Telephone Network]

Great stuff

I see lots and lots of potential
The track is really well produced, kudos on the mixing.
But that's one of the powers of Reason :)
I liked all parts in this, keep on making this kind of stuff, please ^^

mackerelsalad

5'd /10'd

Tome89 responds:

T/Y MackerelSalad! ^w^

[Tome - REM]

Fint!!!

Thanks for your vote, MackerelSalad! You voted 5 for Tome - REM, keeping its score at 5.00.

skitbra!
interesting sounds there, laddie :)
This would fit great in a film noir, really.
Beautiful stuff, keep it up.

Kolla min nya om du har tiden. :)

Tome89 responds:

(sry kan inte kolla in din nya, ar pa internetcafe pa kreta)

I never expected this on this. Hehehe sweet thankies ^^

[==(Troposphere Remix)==]

Tropical, but cold. (?!?!)

nice noise waves building up the track
nice build up anyway, great stuff.
nice sounds and samples.
great, beautiful composition (even tho i think it's Karco's)
Panflute!!!
I don't know why, but this sounds tropical, yet cold in a way. Maybe because you're from NORWAI
interesting mood overall here.

nice piece of ambience.
mackerelsalad

i have a new track up, which you might wanna check out :)
I'ma vote a nice 5 on this.

[SR - CrapnBass -loop-]

:D

I really like this one better than Crackdown.
the craploop sounds fucking ace man!

[SR - Loli-Lops (Tasty)]

IDM/HIPHOP

Lol, I loved the way your sleek IDM beats got 1/2'd and got itself working a nice little underground beat instead, the way you modulated the synth, was subtle, beautiful, no.. cool and shit.
I can't say much but this to be yet another excellent Sinerider production.
you should get your ass signed somewhere, bitch

SineRider responds:

lolthanks :D

[SpK*) - ICE CREAM!]

Funny

This sounds a whole lot better without the cheesy "light drums from sweden" you thought you added to the loop nicely.

[SpK*) - GELATO!]

Nothing worthy of Sweden

Keep to your Penduluminfluenced "idm/dnb" tracks pleeeease.
Sweden is way too great for this cheesy loop here.

[SpK*) - Zimose]

Cheesy

Reaaaaally cheezy, there is better house out there, try listening to some Detroit house, so you may get the idea of using your new samples.

[SpK*) - Twists and Turns]

You need to put in some more effort in your tracks

The main synth lead was propably a sample you put in horribly into the Fruity Slicer, wasn't it? You should adjust timestretching. Minimal hiphop, or abstract hiphop doesn't sound like this. The drums were okay, but the synth bass you put in at the beginning was more of a synth Lil jon would use.
There were some okay rhodes chord coming in after a while, but I didn't dig the feel of the song.
Poor quality, nice ideas, but poorly executed.
I'd like to see you posting less, but better songs on here.